College practice · Worked answers
Related rates shadow problems
In a moving-shadow problem, the shadow length and the shadow tip’s distance from the lamp are different quantities. Label both. Similar triangles connect the geometry; differentiating then tells you which point is moving at which rate.
Separate the person, shadow, and tip
Assume a point light at fixed height H, a person of fixed height h with 0 < h < H, and level ground. Let x be the person’s distance from the lamp, s the shadow length from the person to the tip, and y = x + s the tip’s distance from the lamp.
H/(x + s) = h/s
Cross-multiply: Hs = h(x + s). Since the heights stay fixed, (H − h)s = hx. Therefore:
s′ = [h/(H − h)]x′ and y′ = [H/(H − h)]x′
Walking away gives x′ > 0. Walking toward the lamp gives x′ < 0. The model applies while the person stays on the same side of the lamp and the shadow geometry remains as described.
Choose the rate the question actually asks for
| Wording | Quantity | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Person’s distance from the pole | x | x′ |
| Length of the shadow | s | s′ |
| Shadow tip’s distance from the pole | y = x + s | y′ = x′ + s′ |
The tip is often faster than the person because both the person’s position and shadow length increase. The person’s distance x cancels out of these rate formulas when H and h are fixed.
Work through two examples
Find both rates, then label them
- A lamp is 18 ft high. A 6-ft person walks away at 4 ft/s.
- The shadow-length rate is s′ = 6/(18 − 6) × 4 = 2 ft/s.
- The tip’s distance from the lamp changes at y′ = 4 + 2 = 6 ft/s. An answer of 2 ft/s would be wrong if the question asks for the tip.
Walking back toward the lamp
- A 2-m person walks toward an 8-m light at 1.5 m/s, remaining on the same side. Thus x′ = −1.5 m/s.
- The shadow rate is s′ = 2/(8 − 2) × (−1.5) = −0.5 m/s.
- The tip rate is y′ = −1.5 − 0.5 = −2 m/s. The shadow shortens while its tip moves toward the lamp.
Try it yourself
Choose an answer, then check your reasoning. You can retry any question or open its solution.
Show solution 1
The tip’s distance from the lamp. x runs from the lamp to the person, and s runs from the person to the tip. Together they give the lamp-to-tip distance.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- The person’s height: x and s are distances along the ground. The heights are H and h.
- The shadow length alone: s alone is the shadow length. Adding x gives the distance from the lamp to the tip.
- The person’s distance from the lamp: That is x alone.
Show solution 2
1 ft/s. s′ = 5/(15 − 5) × 2 = 1 ft/s. That is the shadow length’s rate.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 3 ft/s: 3 ft/s is the tip’s rate, y′ = x′ + s′. The shadow length grows more slowly.
- 2 ft/s: That is the walking rate x′, not the shadow’s.
- About 0.67 ft/s: That uses h/H = 5/15. The factor is h/(H − h) = 5/10.
Show solution 3
3 ft/s. y′ = x′ + s′ = 2 + 1 = 3 ft/s.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 1 ft/s: 1 ft/s is s′, the shadow length’s rate. The tip also moves along with the person.
- 2 ft/s: That is just the person’s rate.
- 6 ft/s: That uses H/h = 3. The tip factor is H/(H − h) = 15/10 = 1.5.
Show solution 4
Negative. x is distance from the lamp. That distance decreases while walking toward it, so x′ is negative.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- Positive: x is the distance from the lamp. Walking toward the lamp makes it shrink.
- Always zero: x′ is zero only if the person stands still.
- It depends on how fast they walk: Speed sets the size of x′. Direction sets its sign.
Show solution 5
H/(x + s) = h/s. The large triangle uses height H and base x + s. The small triangle uses height h and base s. Match corresponding sides.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- H/x = h/s: The lamp’s triangle runs all the way to the tip, so its base is x + s, not x.
- H/s = h/x: That pairs each height with the wrong base. The person’s triangle has base s; the lamp’s has base x + s.
- H/(x + s) = h/x: The lamp side is right, but the person’s triangle has the shadow s as its base, not x.
Show solution 6
8 ft/s. s′ = 5/15 × 6 = 2 ft/s, so y′ = 6 + 2 = 8 ft/s. Or directly: y′ = 20/15 × 6 = 8 ft/s.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 2 ft/s: 2 ft/s is s′, the shadow length’s rate. Add the walking rate.
- 6 ft/s: That is just the walking speed.
- 24 ft/s: That uses H/h = 4. The tip factor is H/(H − h) = 20/15.
Show solution 7
It is 2 ft/s at both. s′ = [5/(20 − 5)] × 6 = 2 ft/s at every position. x cancels out of the rate formula when H, h, and x′ are fixed.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- It is 4 times larger at 40 ft: The shadow length s = hx/(H − h) grows with x, but its rate s′ = [h/(H − h)]x′ doesn’t depend on x.
- It shrinks as the person gets farther away: With fixed heights and a steady walk, the factor h/(H − h) never changes, so s′ stays the same.
- It is 0, because the shadow length is fixed: The shadow does get longer as you walk away. Only its rate is constant.
Show solution 8
−0.6 m/s. x′ = −1.4 m/s, so s′ = [1.8/(6 − 1.8)] × (−1.4) = (1.8/4.2)(−1.4) = −0.6 m/s.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- +0.6 m/s: The size is right, but walking toward the lamp shortens the shadow, so s′ is negative.
- −1.4 m/s: That is the person’s rate x′, not the shadow’s.
- −0.42 m/s: That uses h/H = 1.8/6. The factor is h/(H − h) = 1.8/4.2.
Answer key
Open all answers
- The tip’s distance from the lamp. x runs from the lamp to the person, and s runs from the person to the tip. Together they give the lamp-to-tip distance.
- 1 ft/s. s′ = 5/(15 − 5) × 2 = 1 ft/s. That is the shadow length’s rate.
- 3 ft/s. y′ = x′ + s′ = 2 + 1 = 3 ft/s.
- Negative. x is distance from the lamp. That distance decreases while walking toward it, so x′ is negative.
- H/(x + s) = h/s. The large triangle uses height H and base x + s. The small triangle uses height h and base s. Match corresponding sides.
- 8 ft/s. s′ = 5/15 × 6 = 2 ft/s, so y′ = 6 + 2 = 8 ft/s. Or directly: y′ = 20/15 × 6 = 8 ft/s.
- It is 2 ft/s at both. s′ = [5/(20 − 5)] × 6 = 2 ft/s at every position. x cancels out of the rate formula when H, h, and x′ are fixed.
- −0.6 m/s. x′ = −1.4 m/s, so s′ = [1.8/(6 − 1.8)] × (−1.4) = (1.8/4.2)(−1.4) = −0.6 m/s.
Common questions
Why is the shadow tip faster than the person when walking away?
Its distance from the lamp equals person distance plus shadow length. Both increase in this model.
Does the answer depend on how far the person is from the lamp?
For fixed heights and the stated level-ground point-light model, the rate factors depend on the heights, not x.
What if the person changes height or the light moves?
Those quantities are no longer constants. Differentiate the full relation while keeping all changing quantities as variables.
Keep practicing
Try 3 days free3-day free trial, no card needed.
Sources and fact checks
Definitions and methods checked against these textbook references. Practice scenarios and worked numbers were written for this guide.