College practice · Worked answers
Related rates ladder problems
A sliding ladder creates a right triangle whose legs change while the ladder length stays fixed. For these college calculus problems, name the two distances before differentiating. The top and bottom generally move at different speeds.
Define the triangle, including the signs
Let x be the bottom’s distance from the wall, y the top’s height above the floor, and L the fixed ladder length. Assume a vertical wall, level floor, and a rigid ladder whose ends remain in contact. Then x² + y² = L². Distances x and y are positive; their derivatives can be negative.
Differentiate with respect to time while x and y are still variables:
2x dx/dt + 2y dy/dt = 0
dy/dt = −(x/y) dx/dt, for y > 0
When the bottom moves away from the wall, dx/dt is positive. The negative sign predicts that the top falls. Do not replace x and y with their values at one instant until after differentiating.
What changes as the ladder slides?
| Bottom distance x | Height y | Top velocity dy/dt |
|---|---|---|
| 6 ft | 8 ft | −0.75 ft/s |
| 8 ft | 6 ft | −1.333… ft/s |
Even with a constant bottom speed, the top’s velocity changes because x/y changes. The formula blows up as y gets close to zero. Near the floor the real ladder stops behaving like the model, so don’t push the math past that point.
A quick setup check
- Label x, y, and the constant L on your sketch.
- Find a missing distance with the Pythagorean theorem.
- Differentiate the variable equation with respect to time.
- Insert the instant’s distances and the signed known rate.
- Report both the value and the direction, with distance-per-time units.
Work through two examples
The top of a 13-foot ladder
- A 13-foot ladder has its bottom 5 feet from the wall, moving away at 2 ft/s. Find the top’s velocity.
- The top height is y = √(13² − 5²) = 12 ft. Differentiate x² + y² = 169 to get 2x x′ + 2y y′ = 0.
- Substitute: y′ = −(5/12) × 2 = −5/6 ft/s. The top moves downward at 5/6 ft/s.
The bottom moves toward the wall
- A 10-meter ladder has x = 8 m and y = 6 m. The bottom moves toward the wall at 0.3 m/s, so x′ = −0.3 m/s.
- Use y′ = −(x/y)x′ = −(8/6)(−0.3).
- The result is +0.4 m/s. The positive sign means the top rises.
Try it yourself
Choose an answer, then check your reasoning. You can retry any question or open its solution.
Show solution 1
x² + y² = L². The wall and floor form a right angle, so the two distances and ladder satisfy the Pythagorean theorem.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- x + y = L: The legs of a right triangle don’t add up to the hypotenuse. Use the Pythagorean theorem.
- xy = L²: A product of the legs relates to area, not to the ladder length.
- x² − y² = L²: The ladder is the hypotenuse, so the squares of the legs add, not subtract.
Show solution 2
2x x′ + 2y y′. Each squared distance needs the chain rule: d(x²)/dt = 2x x′ and d(y²)/dt = 2y y′.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 2x + 2y: That forgets the chain rule. Each term also needs its rate, x′ or y′.
- x′ + y′: That is the derivative of x + y, not of the squares.
- 2x′ + 2y′: The power rule gives 2x before the chain rule multiplies by x′. Don’t drop the x.
Show solution 3
−1.5 ft/s. y′ = −(6/8) × 2 = −1.5 ft/s. The negative sign agrees with the top falling.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- +1.5 ft/s: The size is right, but the top falls as the bottom slides out, so y′ is negative.
- −2 ft/s: The two ends don’t move at the same speed. Use y′ = −(x/y)x′.
- About −2.67 ft/s: That flips the ratio. Use x/y = 6/8, not y/x = 8/6.
Show solution 4
+0.5 m/s. Rearrange x x′ + y y′ = 0 to x′ = −y y′/x = −5(−1.2)/12 = +0.5 m/s.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- −0.5 m/s: The sign is off. The top drops, so the bottom moves away from the wall and x′ is positive.
- +2.88 m/s: That flips the ratio. x′ = −(y/x)y′, so use 5/12, not 12/5.
- +1.2 m/s: The two ends don’t move at the same rate. x x′ + y y′ = 0 links them through x and y.
Show solution 5
To avoid turning changing quantities into apparent constants. Replacing changing x and y by one instant’s numbers before differentiating loses their time derivatives. You may calculate a missing distance first, but keep variables in the equation you differentiate.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- Because distances cannot be calculated first: You can, and often should, find the missing distance first. Just don’t plug it into the equation before differentiating.
- Because the ladder length changes: The ladder length L is constant. That is why its derivative is zero.
- It doesn’t matter when you substitute: It does. Plugging x = 6 in first makes x look constant, so its derivative would wrongly come out as 0.
Show solution 6
−0.875 ft/s. The height is y = √(25² − 7²) = √576 = 24 ft. Then y′ = −(7/24) × 3 = −0.875 ft/s, so the top falls at 0.875 ft/s.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- −3 ft/s: The two ends don’t share a speed. Use y′ = −(x/y)x′.
- About −10.29 ft/s: That uses y/x = 24/7. The formula is y′ = −(x/y)x′ = −(7/24) × 3.
- +0.875 ft/s: The top slides down while the bottom moves out, so y′ is negative.
Show solution 7
x ≈ 7.07 ft. The speeds are equal when x/y = 1, so x = y. Then 2x² = 100 and x = √50 ≈ 7.07 ft.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- x = 5 ft: Half the ladder length doesn’t make x equal y. At x = 5, y = √75 ≈ 8.66 ft.
- x = 10 ft: At x = 10 the top is on the floor (y = 0), and the model breaks down.
- Never: |y′| = (x/y)|x′|, so the speeds match whenever x = y, which does happen during the slide.
Show solution 8
It increases. The top’s speed is (x/y) × 1 ft/s. As the top nears the floor, x approaches 10 and y approaches 0, so x/y and the top’s speed grow.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- It decreases: As y shrinks, x/y grows, so the top speeds up instead.
- It stays at 1 ft/s: The speeds only match at the instant x = y.
- It stays at 0.75 ft/s: 0.75 ft/s is the value only at x = 6, y = 8. The ratio x/y keeps changing.
Answer key
Open all answers
- x² + y² = L². The wall and floor form a right angle, so the two distances and ladder satisfy the Pythagorean theorem.
- 2x x′ + 2y y′. Each squared distance needs the chain rule: d(x²)/dt = 2x x′ and d(y²)/dt = 2y y′.
- −1.5 ft/s. y′ = −(6/8) × 2 = −1.5 ft/s. The negative sign agrees with the top falling.
- +0.5 m/s. Rearrange x x′ + y y′ = 0 to x′ = −y y′/x = −5(−1.2)/12 = +0.5 m/s.
- To avoid turning changing quantities into apparent constants. Replacing changing x and y by one instant’s numbers before differentiating loses their time derivatives. You may calculate a missing distance first, but keep variables in the equation you differentiate.
- −0.875 ft/s. The height is y = √(25² − 7²) = √576 = 24 ft. Then y′ = −(7/24) × 3 = −0.875 ft/s, so the top falls at 0.875 ft/s.
- x ≈ 7.07 ft. The speeds are equal when x/y = 1, so x = y. Then 2x² = 100 and x = √50 ≈ 7.07 ft.
- It increases. The top’s speed is (x/y) × 1 ft/s. As the top nears the floor, x approaches 10 and y approaches 0, so x/y and the top’s speed grow.
Common questions
Is the speed of the top negative?
Speed is a nonnegative magnitude. The signed derivative of height is negative when the top moves downward.
Can both ends move at constant speeds?
Not generally for a rigid ladder over an interval. A fixed bottom speed produces a changing top speed through the x/y ratio.
What if the wall is not vertical?
The right-triangle model no longer applies as written. Build a new geometric relation for the stated setup.
Keep practicing
Try 3 days free3-day free trial, no card needed.
Sources and fact checks
Definitions and methods checked against these textbook references. Practice scenarios and worked numbers were written for this guide.