College practice · Worked answers
Related rates cone problems
A conical tank problem has two changing dimensions: water depth and surface radius. Similar triangles let you express both with one variable before differentiating. That extra geometry step is what separates a cone problem from a cylinder problem.
Shrink the full tank triangle to the water triangle
Assume a right circular cone with its tip down and water forming a level surface. Let the full tank radius be R and height be H. Let the water radius be r and depth from the tip be h. The tank dimensions are constants, but r and h change together.
r/h = R/H = k, so r = kh
Start with V = (π/3)r²h. Substitute r = kh to get V = (πk²/3)h³. Now differentiate:
dV/dt = πk²h² dh/dt
Use the full-tank ratio R/H, not an unrelated pair of lengths. The radius is not constant just because the tank is rigid; the water surface spreads out as the level rises.
Read the units and the flow direction
| Quantity | Typical units | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| dV/dt | m³/min | Net flow into the tank |
| dh/dt | m/min | Signed change in water depth |
| k = R/H | No units | Fixed shape ratio |
If 7 m³/min enters and 2 m³/min leaves, the net rate is +5 m³/min. Draining alone gives a negative dV/dt. At h = 0 the simplified height-rate formula divides by zero; use it only at positive water depth.
Work through two examples
Water rises in a tip-down tank
- A tank has R = 3 m and H = 6 m. Water enters at 2 m³/min with no outflow. Find h′ when h = 2 m.
- The ratio is k = 1/2. Therefore V = πh³/12 and V′ = (π/4)h²h′.
- At h = 2, 2 = πh′. The depth rises at 2/π ≈ 0.6366 m/min.
The same tank drains
- Use R/H = 1/2, h = 4 m, and net V′ = −3 m³/min.
- Insert values into V′ = π(1/2)²h²h′: −3 = 4πh′.
- Thus h′ = −3/(4π) ≈ −0.2387 m/min. The negative sign describes a falling water level.
Try it yourself
Choose an answer, then check your reasoning. You can retry any question or open its solution.
Show solution 1
r = h/3. Similar triangles give r/h = 4/12 = 1/3, so r = h/3.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- r = 3h: That uses H/R. Similar triangles give r/h = R/H = 4/12.
- r = 4: 4 is the full tank radius. The water radius changes with depth.
- r = h/4: The ratio is R/H = 4/12 = 1/3, not 1/4.
Show solution 2
πh³/27. V = (π/3)(h/3)²h = πh³/27. The squared radius contributes a factor of 1/9.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- πh³/3: That is what you get with r = h. Substitute r = h/3 and square it.
- πh²/9: πh²/9 is πr², the area of the water surface, not a volume.
- πh³/9: That is the cylinder formula πr²h. A cone has an extra factor of 1/3.
Show solution 3
3 m/min. V′ = π(1/4)(4)h′ = πh′. Thus h′ = 3 m/min.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 3π m/min: You didn’t divide out the π in the coefficient πk²h².
- 0.75 m/min: That uses h² = 4 but skips k² = 1/4. The coefficient is π(1/4)(4) = π.
- 12 m/min: That uses k² = 1/4 but forgets h² = 4.
Show solution 4
5 L/min. Net inflow is 9 − 4 = +5 L/min. Convert liters to the volume units used in your geometry before substituting.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 13 L/min: Outflow takes water away, so subtract it.
- −5 L/min: The sign is reversed. More water comes in than goes out, so the volume is increasing.
- 9 L/min: That ignores the outflow.
Show solution 5
It decreases. h′ = V′/(πk²h²). A larger h gives a larger surface area and a smaller height increase per unit time.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- It stays constant: That is true for a cylinder, whose cross-section never changes. A cone widens as it fills.
- It increases: The surface gets wider as h grows, so the same volume makes a thinner layer.
- It increases at first, then decreases: h′ = V′/(πk²h²) shrinks steadily as h grows. There is no turnaround.
Show solution 6
0.6 m³/min. One cubic meter is 1,000 liters, so 600 L/min = 600/1,000 = 0.6 m³/min.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- 600 m³/min: Liters and cubic meters aren’t the same unit. 1 m³ = 1,000 L.
- 6 m³/min: That divides by 100. Divide by 1,000.
- 0.06 m³/min: That divides by 10,000. Divide by 1,000.
Show solution 7
About −0.637 m/min. k = 2/6 = 1/3, so V′ = π(1/9)h²h′. At h = 3, −2 = πh′, giving h′ = −2/π ≈ −0.637 m/min.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- About +0.637 m/min: The size is right, but draining makes the level fall, so h′ is negative.
- About −0.0707 m/min: That leaves out k² = 1/9. The coefficient is π(1/9)(3²) = π, not 9π.
- About −0.159 m/min: That treats the water radius as a constant 2 m, like a cylinder. In a cone, r shrinks with depth.
Show solution 8
The ratio r/h. The water forms a smaller cone with the same shape as the tank, so r/h always equals R/H.
Why the other choices are wrong:
- The water radius r: The water surface widens and narrows with depth, so r changes.
- The water depth h: h changes; its rate is usually what you are solving for.
- The water volume V: V changes as water flows in or out; its rate is V′.
Answer key
Open all answers
- r = h/3. Similar triangles give r/h = 4/12 = 1/3, so r = h/3.
- πh³/27. V = (π/3)(h/3)²h = πh³/27. The squared radius contributes a factor of 1/9.
- 3 m/min. V′ = π(1/4)(4)h′ = πh′. Thus h′ = 3 m/min.
- 5 L/min. Net inflow is 9 − 4 = +5 L/min. Convert liters to the volume units used in your geometry before substituting.
- It decreases. h′ = V′/(πk²h²). A larger h gives a larger surface area and a smaller height increase per unit time.
- 0.6 m³/min. One cubic meter is 1,000 liters, so 600 L/min = 600/1,000 = 0.6 m³/min.
- About −0.637 m/min. k = 2/6 = 1/3, so V′ = π(1/9)h²h′. At h = 3, −2 = πh′, giving h′ = −2/π ≈ −0.637 m/min.
- The ratio r/h. The water forms a smaller cone with the same shape as the tank, so r/h always equals R/H.
Common questions
Why can’t I hold r constant?
The water surface radius changes with depth in a tip-down cone. The full tank radius R is constant; the water radius r is not.
What if the cone points upward?
The similar-triangle setup changes. Do not reuse r/h = R/H without defining h and checking the geometry.
Can I mix liters and meters?
Convert first. One cubic meter is 1,000 liters, so a flow in L/min must be converted if all dimensions are in meters.
Keep practicing
Try 3 days free3-day free trial, no card needed.
Sources and fact checks
Definitions and methods checked against these textbook references. Practice scenarios and worked numbers were written for this guide.